CheckoutMain: more shops near youOpen today 10 AM – 12 AM · Must be 21+ to purchase
Just Wine & Liquor
Directions
Old FashionedBourbon · Bitters · Sugar
  • 2 oz bourbon
  • 2 dashes bitters
  • Sugar cube, orange peel
1880Year of creation

Classic cocktail

Old Fashioned

Bourbon · Bitters · Sugar

Whiskey, sugar, bitters and a little water: the first definition of a cocktail, and still the best argument for one.

On the shelf tonight
GlassRocks, one big cube
MethodMuddle, build and stir
GarnishOrange peel, a cherry if you like
StrengthSpirit-forward
The story1880Pendennis Club, Louisville

The cocktail, as first defined.In 1806 a newspaper in upstate New York answered a reader who wanted to know what a cocktail was: spirits of any kind, sugar, water and bitters. That is the whole recipe. For most of the century a "whiskey cocktail" meant exactly this.

Old-fashioned, by request.By the 1880s bartenders were adding liqueurs and absinthe to everything, and drinkers who wanted the plain version started asking for an old-fashioned whiskey cocktail. Louisville's Pendennis Club claims the name, with a bourbon distiller named James E. Pepper said to have carried the drink to the bar of the Waldorf-Astoria in New York.

Today. Kentucky made it the official state cocktail in 2015. The bottle is the drink: a bourbon with some weight to it, a dash of bitters, and the patience to stir rather than shake.

Ingredients
  • Bourbon1792 12 YEARS · $69.992 oz
  • Aromatic bittersNot on the shelf today2 dashes
  • Sugar cube, or ¼ oz simple syrupFrom your kitchen1
  • Orange, for the garnishFrom your kitchen1 peel
  • Ice, one large cubeFrom your kitchen1
A bottle of bourbon makes about 12 drinks; the bitters outlast it by a year. The set, at the prices on the shelf:$69.99
Preparation
1

Put a sugar cube in a rocks glass, soak it with two dashes of bitters and a splash of water, and muddle until it dissolves.

2

Add one large ice cube and pour 2 oz bourbon over it.

3

Stir for about 20 seconds, until the drink is cold and slightly diluted.

4

Twist an orange peel over the glass and drop it in. A cherry is your call.

Never muddle the fruit into it. The orange is a garnish, not an ingredient.

Same glass, one bottle swapped

Each a drink of its own, each bottle on the shelf tonight

Also on the wall

All 7
1 of 2 tonight · no aromatic bittersPay at the counter, 860 Atlantic Ave.

UNDER STATE LAW, ANY PACKAGE STORE IS ENTITLED TO BUY ANY ITEM OF LIQUOR OR WINE SHOWN IN THIS ADVERTISEMENT AT THE SAME PRICE PAID BY THE STORES LISTED IN THIS AD. UNDER STATE LAW, RETAILERS MAY NOT SELL LIQUOR OR WINE BELOW LEGALLY ESTABLISHED MINIMUM PRICES. THE LISTED STORES ARE INDEPENDENTLY OWNED AND OPERATED, THEY ARE NOT A CHAIN AND ARE NOT A COOPERATIVE BUYING GROUP.